Limitations of Arrhenius theory:
A)The definition of acids and bases are limited to aqueous solution only.
B)Acidic nature of substances which do not contain H+ and basic nature of substances which do not contain OH- were not explained.
Example: CO2, SO2(acidic oxides), NH3 ,Na2O(Bases)
C)There are some substance which do not contain H+ and OH- but can neutralise acids and a base.
\( CO_2 + 2NaOH\xrightarrow{{}}Na_2 CO_3 + H_2 O \)
\( NH_3 + HCl\xrightarrow{{}}NH_4 Cl \)
\( CaO + CO_2 \xrightarrow{{}}CaCO_3 \)
D)Studies on solutions showed that H+ ions do not have independent existence and exist as H3O+. This is in contradiction to Arrhenius theory.
\( (H^ + + H_2 O\xrightarrow{{}}H_3 O^ + ) \)
Modified version of Arrhenius theory:
It rectifies most of the above limitations
(i) Water is weak electrolyte and ionises to a very weak extent.
H2O \( \rightleftharpoons \) H+ + OH–
H+ + H2O \( \rightleftharpoons \) H3 O+
H2O + H2O \( \rightleftharpoons \) H3 O+ + OH–
Above reaction is called Autoionisation or selfionisation of water.
(ii) Water is neutral in nature i.e.[H3O+] = [OH–]
(iii) The substances which increase the H3O+ ion concentration act as acids and while those which increase OH– ion concentration act as bases.
Ex.A) SO2 + H2O \( \to \) H2SO3 \( \rightleftharpoons \) H3O+ + HSO3–
Acid
B) NH3 + H2O \( \to \) NH4OH \( \rightleftharpoons \) NH4+ + OH–
Base
In order to account for these drawbacks, an advanced theory was introduced the protonic concept of acids and bases or Lowry - Bronsted theory of acids and bases.